Chapter 05 · Limits
Your notes
Bookmarks
Calculator
05.01
Determining Limits Graphically
What a limit is: the value f(x) heads toward as x gets close to a number. Estimate limits from tables, read them from graphs, tell a limit apart from the function's value, find one-sided limits, and recognize the ways a limit can fail to exist.
About 40 minutes
You'll learn to
- →Explain what a limit means, and read and write limit notation
- →Estimate a limit from a table of values, and know when a table can mislead
- →Read a limit from a graph, and tell it apart from the function's value
- →Find one-sided limits from a graph or a piecewise formula
- →Decide whether a limit exists, and recognize jumps, unbounded growth and oscillation
Summary video coming soon
A short video recap of the whole lesson is on its way.
1. The idea of a limit
Video coming soon
A short video for this part is on its way. Everything you need is in the text below.
Calculus asks questions like "how fast is the car going at this instant?" and "how steep is this curve at this point?" Both run into the same wall: the obvious formula breaks down exactly where we want the answer. Speed is distance over time, and over an instant no time passes, so the formula divides by zero. Limits get around the wall. Instead of looking at the troublesome point, we look at what happens near it, and ask where things are heading.
Approaching a number
Take and let get close to , from below and from above:
From both sides the outputs close in on . We say the limit of as approaches is , and write
The arrow is read "approaches", and the whole line is read "the limit of as approaches is ."
means that we can make as close to as we like by taking close enough to , on either side, but not equal to . (This is the informal definition.)
"As close as we like" and "close enough" are made precise with and in section 05.07. For the first half of this chapter, the picture of the outputs closing in is all we need.
Near , not at
The phrase "but not equal to " is the heart of the definition.
The value plays no part in the limit: it may agree with the limit, disagree with it, or not exist at all.
That's exactly what makes limits useful, because the places calculus cares about are often the places where a formula can't be evaluated.
Let for every , and . As approaches , the outputs close in on , and the one value at is ignored:
isn't defined at : substituting gives . But for every the factor cancels (section 03.08), so there, and near the outputs are near :
A limit can exist where the function doesn't. Lesson section 05.03 is all about limits like this one.
Notation
- is also written " as ".
- The letter is only a placeholder: is the same limit as .
- is an input (an -value) and is an output (a height on the graph).
- Using as the limit. Often they're equal, but not always: in "A value that disagrees", the limit is and the value is . Always ask where the outputs are heading.
- " is undefined, so the limit doesn't exist." In "No value at all", is undefined and the limit is .
- Answering with the -value. In , the is where goes; the limit is the output, .
A limit is the value heads toward as gets close to a number :
Limit notation
says "as approaches , from either side and without ever equaling , approaches ."
A limit is about what happens near , never at : can be a different number, or not exist at all.
If for every , but , then , even though .
2. Estimating limits from tables
Video coming soon
A short video for this part is on its way. Everything you need is in the text below.
When a function has no convenient graph, or substituting gives , a calculator can still give evidence about a limit.
Building a table
- Choose inputs that approach from the left: , , .
- Choose inputs that approach from the right: , , .
- Evaluate at each, and look for a single number that both rows close in on.
(with from section 03.15) isn't defined at . Near :
From the left the outputs climb toward , and from the right they fall toward . The table suggests
and that's right: section 06.04 shows why. Notice that no entry is ; the limit is the number the entries are closing in on.
For near :
The left row heads for and the right row for . There's no single number both sides approach, so does not exist. Checking only one side would have given a wrong answer.
Tables can mislead
A table only looks at a few inputs, and those inputs can be unlucky.
- Special inputs. For at , every entry is : . But in between, at for instance, . Near the function swings between and infinitely often, and the limit does not exist. The table's zeros came from the choice of inputs.
- Rounding. On a calculator, is about at and at , closing in on . At , though, the calculator rounds to exactly and reports . Inputs that are too close can lose all their digits.
So treat a table as evidence: it tells you what to expect. A graph, and later algebra (section 05.02), confirms it.
- Checking only one side. In "The two sides disagree", the right side alone suggests ; the left side shows there's no limit.
- Reporting an entry instead of the limit. is a value of , not the limit. The limit is the number the entries approach.
- Trusting a pattern from special inputs. Inputs like are convenient, but a function can do something different in between.
To estimate with a table, evaluate at inputs closer and closer to from both sides, and look for one number that both sides close in on. A table suggests a limit; it can't prove one, and special inputs can fool it.
at gives , , and , , : the limit as appears to be .
3. Reading limits from a graph
Video coming soon
A short video for this part is on its way. Everything you need is in the text below.
A graph shows all the outputs at once, which makes limits easy to see.
The finger test
Put a finger on the curve a little to the left of and slide it toward . Do the same from the right. If both fingers head for the same height , then . Neither finger ever lands on : the limit is decided by the curve near , not by any point at .
Open and closed dots
- An open dot (a hole) marks a point that is not on the graph. The curve heads toward it, but doesn't take that value there.
- A closed dot marks a point that is on the graph: it shows . A closed dot away from the curve means the function's value has been moved somewhere else.
Open in grapher (opens in a new tab)
The graph follows the parabola , with an open dot at and a closed dot at .
- The limit at . From both sides, the curve heads for the hole at height , so .
- The value at . The closed dot says . The limit and the value are different numbers.
- An ordinary point. At the curve is unbroken, so . At most points of most graphs, the limit is just the value. The interesting cases are the breaks.
Three things a graph can show at
| At the graph has… | ||
|---|---|---|
| an unbroken curve | the curve's height | the same height |
| a hole, and no dot | the hole's height | undefined |
| a hole, and a dot elsewhere | the hole's height | the dot's height |
In every row, the limit comes from the curve; the dot never decides it.
The first row, where the limit and the value agree, is what it means for to be continuous at (section 05.11).
- Reading the closed dot. The dot is . The limit is where the curve is heading.
- "There's a hole, so there's no limit." A hole is a missing value. Both sides still head for its height, so the limit is the hole's height.
- Giving the -coordinate. A limit is an output: read it on the -axis.
To read from a graph, trace the curve toward from the left and from the right, and read the height both sides head for. An open dot is a missing point; a closed dot is the function's value. Whatever happens exactly at doesn't affect the limit.
Below, , but .
4. One-sided limits
Video coming soon
A short video for this part is on its way. Everything you need is in the text below.
Sometimes a function heads for one height from the left and a different height from the right. To talk about each side on its own, we use one-sided limits.
Notation
means approaches as approaches through values less than .
means approaches as approaches through values greater than .
The little and are about the direction, not the sign of the numbers: means , and means .
Open in grapher (opens in a new tab)
From the left, follows down to the filled dot at . From the right, it follows toward the open dot at . So
The right-hand limit is even though the point is missing: like a two-sided limit, a one-sided limit ignores itself.
Piecewise functions (section 03.07) switch formulas at a break, so each side of the break has its own formula. Let
Just left of , uses , which approaches . Just right of , uses , which approaches . So and . (The value comes from the second formula too, but that's a value, not a limit.)
One-sided and two-sided limits
if and only if and .
This makes sense: "close to on either side" means close from the left and close from the right. So at a break, find each one-sided limit:
- Equal: the two-sided limit is that number.
- Different: the two-sided limit does not exist, as for at and at above.
Let for and for , with undefined. From the left, ; from the right, . The one-sided limits agree, so , even though doesn't exist.
- Reading as "negative ". means approaches from below:
- Using the same formula on both sides. Each side of the break uses its own piece. The piece that includes gives , not both one-sided limits.
- Deciding a two-sided limit from one side. Both sides must agree.
is the left-hand limit (approach through ); is the right-hand limit (). The two-sided limit exists exactly when both one-sided limits exist and are equal:
For when and when : and .
5. When a limit does not exist
Video coming soon
A short video for this part is on its way. Everything you need is in the text below.
A limit exists when the outputs settle down near one number. When they don't, we say the limit does not exist, written DNE in answers.
Here are the three ways it usually happens.
1. A jump
If the one-sided limits are different numbers, the graph jumps, and no single height is approached from both sides. For in the previous concept, and , so does not exist. Each one-sided limit exists; only the two-sided one fails.
2. Unbounded growth
Near , takes the values at , at , at : it grows past every number, and its graph shoots up along the vertical asymptote (section 03.12). It doesn't approach any number, so the limit doesn't exist as a number. Because it fails in such a definite way, there's a special notation for it, , which section 05.05 makes precise. For , the right side shoots up and the left side shoots down: it fails in two different ways at once.
3. Oscillation
Open in grapher (opens in a new tab)
As , races through larger and larger numbers, so runs through complete cycles of the sine wave faster and faster. Every interval around , however small, contains inputs where (where ) and inputs where . The outputs never settle, so
What matters is whether the heights settle down, not whether the graph wiggles. A graph can wiggle forever and still have a limit, if the wiggles get flatter and flatter.
What is not a reason for DNE
- A hole. A missing point at doesn't stop the curve from heading somewhere.
- being undefined, or different. The limit never looks at .
- A formula that changes at . Piecewise functions often have limits at their breaks, when the pieces meet.
To decide whether exists from a graph: look at each side. Does the left side head for a number? Does the right side? Are they the same number? Only "yes, yes, yes" gives a limit. For in the tables concept, the answers were "yes (), yes (), no": DNE.
- "DNE" because of a hole or a moved dot. The limit is the height of the hole.
- "The limit is " at a jump. At a jump, the value sits on one side; the two-sided limit still doesn't exist.
- Calling every wiggly graph DNE. Check whether the heights settle on one number.
does not exist (DNE) when doesn't settle on one number near . Three common ways:
- a jump: the one-sided limits are different numbers;
- unbounded growth: grows without bound near , as at a vertical asymptote;
- oscillation: keeps swinging between values, however close gets.
does not exist: near the graph swings between and infinitely often.
Ready for more? The Practice tab has 14 more problems on the whole lesson.
Definitions
- Limit
means gets as close to as we like when is close enough to , on either side, with .
- Left-hand limit
: approaches as approaches through values less than .
- Right-hand limit
: approaches as approaches through values greater than .
- Limit and value
The limit at depends only on for near ; the value plays no part. They can be equal, different, or one can exist without the other.
- Open and closed dots
On a graph, an open dot (a hole) is a point that is missing; a closed dot is a point on the graph, showing the function's value.
- Does not exist (DNE)
A limit does not exist when doesn't approach a single number: for example at a jump, near a vertical asymptote, or where oscillates.
- Jump
A break where the one-sided limits exist but are different numbers. The two-sided limit does not exist there.
- Oscillation
Outputs that keep swinging between values as , like near , so they never settle on one number.
Formulas
Limit notation
"the limit of as approaches is "
One-sided limits
When a two-sided limit exists
A table's inputs
approach from both sides; the table suggests a limit but doesn't prove it
Study
Apply it
Real-world problems that take several steps. Work through them one step at a time, with each step checked as you go.
Practice
14 practice problems with instant feedback, hints and worked solutions.
Sign up free to practice